In Sunday's episode of Paramount+’s Evil, aptly titled “C is for Cop,” it’s racist cops and white privilege that constitute this week’s evil entity.
The episode opens with Officer Jim Turley (Corey Cott) pulling over and ultimately shooting a black woman, after he thinks he sees her reaching for a gun, which turns out to be a cell phone. The officer so genuinely believes he saw a gun that he is going to go with an insanity defense based on demonic possession.
That is where the main characters come in, whose job it is to determine whether or not those the Catholic Church brings before them are indeed demonically possessed. David (Mike Colter) is a black seminarian soon to be a priest, Kristen (Katja Herbers) is a lapsed Catholic and a forensic psychologist, and Ben (Aasif Mandvi) is a technology contractor. The three don’t even try to hide their assumption that Turley is racist once they find out he's white.
Bishop Marx: Do you want me to explain myself?
David: Yes, that would be good.
Bishop Marx: I took this meeting as a favor.
Kristen: Well, great. We took the meeting. Favor fulfilled. What’s next?
Bishop Marx: Wait. We need to discuss this.
Ben; What ‘this?’ A racist cop killed a Black mother, and now he wants the Catholic Church to give him a…
Kristen: Twinkie defense?
Bishop Marx: I want you to meet with him.
Ben: The racist cop?
Bishop Marx: You don’t know if he’s a racist.
Kristen: Oh.
Bishop Marx: We have to learn to withhold judgment. David, as a man of God, you must withhold ju… Where are you going?
David: To withhold judgment.
The three immediately go to speak with Turley and he not only acknowledges he’s done wrong and admits that he may have acted differently had he pulled over a white woman, but he's insistent on what he saw.
A polygraph test reveals that Officer Turley, in fact, did believe he saw a gun. David cynically asks, “Does it matter?” clarifying it “just means he expected there to be a gun due to the driver’s race.” Bishop Marx, however, cuts in to ask, “Is it not also possible that Satan uses racism as a form of diabolical oppression?”
David, Kristen, and Ben go to meet with Mick Carr (Fredric Lehne), the creator of the world’s most popular cop show, Justice Served. He’s supposed to be like Dick Wolf and his Law & Order franchise.
In a scene of dialogue that has David sounding like a representative from Color of Change, a Black Lives Matter partner which sees itself as being responsible for forcing television shows to change how they portray police, Carr brags about how he’s positively impacted the industry.