Maine Athlete Speaks Out Against Having to Compete Against Biological Boys

Brittany M. Hughes | March 24, 2025
DONATE
Text Audio
00:00 00:00
Font Size

Cassidy Carlisle was only in the seventh grade when she said she was forced to change clothes in a locker room in front of a gender-confused boy at Presque Isle Middle School - her first experience as one of many students impacted by Maine’s “trans-inclusive” policies allowing students to be treated according to their gender “identity” at the expense of girls' privacy, safety, and fairness in sports.

Four years later, Carlisle found herself facing another, even more demoralizing scenario when she was told she’d be competing against a biological male in a skiing competition, a decision made outside her control that wound up changing her high school athletic career.

“I was like, ‘Oh, that’s only something I kind of hear about on the news. It’s not going to happen to me,” Cassidy remembers about the moment she learned she’d be skiing against a guy.

Being an accomplished Nordic skier wasn’t enough to overcome the biological advantage of a male competitor, and Carlisle lost the race.

Despite finding her loss “heartbreaking,” Carlisle said she felt like she couldn’t come forward for fear of backlash from other students and her own teachers, administrators, and even the public.

“I stayed silent for a while,” Carlisle said. “It’s very hard to speak up if you don’t have a platform to do it on."

"Backlash is a huge thing. I’m a high school student," she went on. "No high school student wants to be hurt or yelled at or said mean comments by people. And the reality of it, with the state that I live in, that could very much happen.” 

Related: Biological Boy Obliterates Competition, Sets 'New Records' At Girls' High School Track Meet

But now, she’s speaking out, both in her own defense and for all the girls who risk losing their championships, scholarships, and even their own physical health to gender-deluded boys who are being allowed to compete in girls’ sports.

Carlisle is just one of many female athletes in Maine who’ve come forward to protest Democrat Gov. Janet Mills’ defiance of President Donald Trump’s recent executive order mandating all publicly funded schools and institutions require students to compete in sports and use facilities in accordance with their biological gender, or risk losing their federal funding.

Last week, the eight public schools under the University of Maine System (UMS) announced they would be reversing course and complying with Trump’s executive order to keep boys out of girls’ sports after the U.S. Department of Agriculture temporarily paused USDA funding over the university system’s continued inclusion of gender-confused males in women’s sports.

Trump had previously sparred with Mills during a meeting with state governors at the White House back in February over her refusal to comply with the executive order. At the time, Mills, a Democrat, had arrogantly vowed to challenge Trump in court over his threat to withhold funding from schools that allow boys to compete in girls’ sports.