News is emerging from Minnesota that the U.S. House-passed “Reconciliation” budget’s intention to end funding to Planned Parenthood (PP) and President Donald Trump’s stated intention to freeze federal funds already have led to the closing of numerous slaughterhouses in the state – and it seems logical for pro-life advocates to assume that more closures will follow.
Tory van Oot reports for Axios:
“Planned Parenthood North Central States said Friday that it plans to close over a third of its health centers across Minnesota and Iowa and lay off dozens of staff members in light of looming federal funding cuts and other budget constraints.”
And Thomas Stevenson writes for the Post Millennial that the recent House passage of the “Reconciliation” Budget – now being hashed out in the Senate – is not the only factor behind the closures:
“Around a third of the organization's staff in the region are set to be laid off, and the leaders of the regional chapters said that the decision was based on the Trump administration's decision to freeze $2.8 million in federal funds that contributed to the organization.
The abortion provider was also facing broader challenges such as staff shortages and other factors, the outlet stated. Although federal funds cannot be used directly for abortions, money is fungible, and Republicans have fought to prevent federal funds from going to the largest abortion organization in the country. Around 30 percent of its patients also use Medicaid, and Republicans are looking to prohibit Medicaid funds from going to the abortion provider, according to PBS.”
Stevenson also notes that 66 staff members are going to be laid off, while 37 have “received offers to be reassigned elsewhere.”
Related: Formerly Leftist Court UPHOLDS Trump’s Ban on Abortion Funding
The sheer number of abortion mill “clients” per year, and the number of “clinics” in Minnesota and four other states in the region are staggering.
Reports Axios:
“Planned Parenthood North Central States (PPNCS) says it provides sexual and reproductive health care, including abortions, to an estimated 93,000 people across Iowa, Minnesota, Nebraska, North Dakota, and South Dakota each year.”
And, though leftist hand-wringers will claim that federal funds generally cannot be used for abortions, any sensible person knows that funds are fungible.
Donald Trump in his first term attempted to stop U.S. tax funds from being funneled to Planned Parenthood through what is called “Title X” family “counseling”, and we at MRCTV celebrated that move. But regardless of the controversial and immoral result, perhaps Americans could look at the U.S. Constitution and notice that politicians in D.C. are not supposed to snatch our tax cash or dig deeper into debt in order to unconstitutionally hand out money for the darkly sinful act of baby-killing, or for ANY of the so-called “beneficent services” like “family counseling,” or cancer screenings, or anything else PP tells people it offers.
Not one moment of it should be funded through the coercive act of government threat.
Of course, advocates of tax money being spent on abortions or “other services” from PP already proudly display their lack of respect for the lives of others, so, consequently, one can understand their similar lack of respect for the earnings and ethical beliefs of taxpayers.
At Axios, Oot reports that Minnesota has seen an increase in abortions after the U.S. Supreme Court sent the legality matter back to the states with its “Dobbs” decision:
“Minnesota has seen an increase in both abortions and out-of-state patients seeking abortion care in the wake of the 2022 U.S. Supreme Court decision overturning Roe v. Wade. Abortions in Iowa, meanwhile, dropped 60% in the first six months after the state began enforcing one of the nation's strictest bans.”
So, logically, wouldn’t it be a good thing in the least, to decentralize the funding of abortion, thus allowing people in Iowa to stop subsidizing Planned Parenthood mills in a nearby state?
And could we apply that to individuals, and let each of us be free, rather than shackled by government to others?
Oot notes:
“Planned Parenthood said its 15 remaining health centers across the chapter's region, including about a dozen in Minnesota and Iowa, will remain open.
Those sites, combined with virtual care, serve about 80% of its current patient population.”
And, of course, if Planned Parenthood is providing solely health-sustaining medical services, rather than a mixture of such services along with murder-for-hire, they should be competing for clients, competing in a free market that incentivizes quality and lower prices.
Instead, politicians take our money and fund abortion mills, cloaking their mass slaughter in rhetoric such as “family planning” and “essential health care.”
That would be human health. And fetuses are, by definition, human beings. At the moment of conception they are human – with their own distinct, individual DNA – and they are “beings” – living, on the grand arc of natural life. The interference by another person into such a life is immoral, and if a state has statutes punishing such attacks on humans outside the womb, the U.S. Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment requires that the states protect all people equally.
But few national – or state – level politicians want to acknowledge that fact.
And, even if real “health care” were the sole role of PP, that should not be funded through tax theft and redistribution of wealth.
Trump’s stated intent to freeze allocated funding, and the current budget goal of removing abortion funds from Medicaid are worthwhile, but ethically consistent Americans also can recognize that even Medicaid runs counter to the Founders’ vision and the fundamentals of peaceful human coexistence. One need not debate about fungible Planned Parenthood accounting to know that it is immoral to take money from another person.
Some ends are worse than others. But the ends need not be debated, because the means is the immoral predicate, and should be a non-starter in the United States.