PA Gov. Shapiro Claims Keeping Men Out of Women’s Sports Is 'Extremist'

P. Gardner Goldsmith | July 28, 2025
DONATE
Text Audio
00:00 00:00
Font Size

In a stunning display of political posturing, Pennsylvania Governor Josh Shapiro recently labeled supporters of a bill banning biological males from women’s sports as “extremists.” This rhetorical flourish, reported by The College Fix, not only mischaracterizes a common-sense stance but also sidesteps the core issue: the state’s obligation under the Fourteenth Amendment to ensure equal protection under the law.

Dave Huber writes for The College Fix on a state bill called SB Nine:

“In his first public remarks about the ‘Save Women’s Sports’ bill, Shapiro said ‘What we do not need in Pennsylvania are politicians — extremist politicians like Donald Trump, [State Senator] Doug Mastriano, and these others — trying to legislate a student’s participation and legislate the restriction on freedom…’”

Which is curious, coming from a guy who heads a state that last year forced taxpayers to “participate” in funding state universities and community colleges to the tune of $894.8 million.

That’s nearly a BILLION DOLLARS, and that is just PART of the forced “education system” inclusion, which comprises the “Pennsylvania State System of Higher Education” (PASSHE), overseeing 10 state-owned universities, (by the way, PASSHE received a 6% funding increase, amounting to an additional $35.1 million for the 2024–25 fiscal year and bringing the total state appropriation for PASSHE to approximately $617.6 million) and also includes Pennsylvania’s 15 community colleges. Those received a 6% funding increase, totaling an additional $15.7 million for the 2024–25 fiscal year, bringing the total appropriation to approximately $277.2 million.

But Governor Shapiro likes to pose as a politician who doesn’t like politicians mixing state power with educational decisions.

Get it?

To be fair, S.B. 9 likely will not pass the House - but by dismissing the “Save Women’s Sports” bill as extremist, Shapiro undermines the biological reality that men and women differ physically—a reality with profound implications for basic fairness and safety in athletic competition.

One of the most basic principles in U.S. history is expressed in the Fourteenth Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause, which mandates that states protect all people equally. But, of course, allowing biological males to compete in women’s sports places female athletes at a clear disadvantage, and, in some cases, in physical danger. This isn’t speculation; it’s grounded in observable differences in muscle mass, bone density, and testosterone levels that give men, on average, superior strength, speed, and endurance in athletic activities. To ignore this is to ignore science, and for the state to sanction such policies is to fail in its duty to protect all citizens equally. If women are forced to compete against men posing as women, the state is not only neglecting fairness but also exposing female athletes to heightened risks of injury—a clear violation of equal protection.

Curiously, as Huber notes, just 10 days before this “extremist” remark, Shapiro stated that biological males “shouldn’t get a special advantage on the field.” Yet, in his first public comments on the “Save Women’s Sports” bill, he pivoted, claiming:

“What we do not need in Pennsylvania are politicians — extremist politicians like Donald Trump, [State Senator] Doug Mastriano, and these others — trying to legislate a student’s participation and legislate the restriction on freedom.”

This flip-flop hints that Shapiro is a politician more concerned with signaling than with addressing the substantive issue of biological differences in sports.

Recognizing that men and women are physically distinct is not “extremist”—it’s an acknowledgment of reality. Studies consistently show that men, on average, possess greater muscle mass and higher testosterone levels, and have quicker reflexes and better depth perception than females, conferring advantages in strength and speed that no amount of hormone therapy fully negates. For example, a 2020 study published in the British Journal of Sports Medicine found that even after years of testosterone suppression, biological males retain significant strength advantages over females.

Are facts “extremist” Governor?

Shapiro’s reluctance to commit to vetoing the bill—he called it a “hypothetical” since it’s stalled in the Democratic-controlled House—suggests he’s aware of the political tightrope.

But is he aware of the reason for all of this bickering?

The wellspring of the problem is not the “trans” issue. That’s an offshoot of the collectivist funding system, which is the reason Shapiro and others keep arguing. Remove the taxation, the force, and only people who want to be tied to something actually become involved. If people can remove THEMSELVES from a system, their preferences become revealed, they don’t have to argue, and real values are reflected through popularity and prosperity.

Not only is biological reality hidden when government weaves itself into education and sports, ethical human interaction is crushed, leaving people to face off in a never-ending form of political battle no one really wins.

Photo by: Josh Shapiro DNC ABC news screenshot