Aug. 4, 2016 . Nicholas Fondacaro

Following the recent revelations from the Wall Street Journal, that the US payed Iran a large sum of money at the same time as they released American hostages, has led many to believe to US payed a ransom for their release. But that couldn’t possibly be the case according to CNN Commentator Peter Beinart who ridiculously declared, on Anderson Cooper 360 Thursday, “It's not ransom if you are giving people their own money, which is what we were doing here.”

Beinart’s comment came as he was trying to write off people’s concerns and defend the Obama administration. When host John Berman noted that information about the unmarked plane and the timing of the transfer was new information Beinart brushed it off saying, “Sure, they had details in this Wall Street Journal.” But, “This was money that we owed the Iranians,” he argued.

He fumbled to put his defense into words as he invoked international law as a reason we needed to repay the Iranians. “The truth is, if they had not delivered this probably we were going to have to give significantly more. We would lose that case at The Hague.” The writer for The Atlantic seemed perturbed by the assertion that the $400 million, in seized Iranian money, could possibly be a ransom, exclaiming, “It's not ransom if you are giving people their own money, which is what we were doing here.” Beinart then went on to defend the Iran deal as a whole and hammered its critics.

But New York City Councilman Joseph Borelli was not standing for Beinart’s argument:

You have the Iranian state TV saying this is a ransom. The Iranian public believes this is ransom. Iranian leadership believes this is ransom … The American public believes this is ransom. For all intents and purposes it's ransom. You can call it whatever you want. But the American public sees it as ransom. Other countries see it as a ransom payment and that's the problem. Shame on the president for now seeing that if he couldn’t.

But of course one could pay off a ransom for a loved one with the kidnapping party’s own money. The fact that one had the kidnapping party’s money to begin with would be a good enough reason to commit the kidnapping.  

You might also like
Donate to uncover the truth
Make a difference and support the Media Research Center